A Muppet Fan’s Dilemma: An Open Letter to My Fandom

Dear all of my Muppet friends from Muppet Central, The Muppet Mindset, ToughPigs, Facebook, Twitter and all over the world,

Would you agree when I say that describing this past month as a ‘complete and utter nightmare’ is a vast understatement?

I knew you would.

I’m not writing this to call any of you out or to start a completely new conversation. I think we can all agree that it isn’t necessary. I’d just like the opportunity to provide my own thoughts and experiences from the past few weeks. All I could ever ask of you is to please put aside a few minutes of your time so that I may tell my story.

Being fickle over my position as a Muppet fan has caused me more trouble than I care to admit over the past few weeks. Actually, perhaps I should be more specific: being a Steve Whitmire fan has pretty much taken over my life since the announcement that he had “left” the Muppets was released. Of course, we all saw what a tragic crap-fest that wound up escalating into. For the sake of what is left of my sanity, I will decline to go into depth about anything Steve, Disney or the Henson’s have said about each other over the past two weeks. You all already know about that and quite frankly, it has been discussed to death.

Something I do want to touch upon, however, is where I feel I must go from here. Over-discussed or not, the Muppets just lost one of their most prominent performers, leaving a gaping hole where Steve once stood. Not to mention that Steve is my all-time favourite performer, whether in the Muppets, Fraggle Rock or even The Dark Crystal. Steve’s characters appealed to me due to the wonderful and enduring personalities he gave to them. He didn’t just give a great performance, he gave an astounding sense of life to whatever puppet was placed in front of him. No matter what was said or done to cause his dismissal, losing Steve as a Muppet Performer is a huge loss to me as a fan and I can’t see myself getting so easily over it any time soon.

I never thought I would have to separate being a Whitmire fan from being a Muppet fan. Allow me to elaborate what I mean by that. Of course I’ll remain a dedicated Muppet enthusiast, but not nearly in the same way as before. For the past five years, I’ve been a Muppet fan because I was a Whitmire fan, not the other way around. I’ve always cared about Steve and the other performers more than the characters themselves. As far as I’m concerned, the Muppets are one of the benefits provided by this exclusive group of amazing talents.

So where does the majority of my loyalties lie in such a confusing time? Do I stick with the crazy cast of characters who for better or for worse completely turned my world on it’s head? Or the man who brought me into this crazy fandom in the first place who I greatly respect and wish to learn a lot more from? Well, my answer finally fell into place thanks to a quote from Steve’s latest post on Muppet Pundit:

“In the big picture, it is not unsupportive of any individual or entity to choose on the side of what is best for the Muppets, themselves, to insure that they have their best chance to go on as a solid, viable ensemble made up of fully intact individuals.”

To sum up what Steve is saying in my own words: if we truly want what is best for the Muppets as time goes onward, if we expect them to remain true to themselves rather than gradually fade to shadows, it is extremely important to look out for the best interests for the characters. This is so much more than just one lone puppeteer or a dedicated fandom, it’s the future of the characters we love that’s more important than any of our individual wants and needs. Say what you want about Steve’s blog; whether you find him to be genuine or ‘self-serving’, he has a fair point.

Steve is not ready to drop the subject….and neither am I. Here is where being a Whitmire and Muppet fan begins to fuse back together. So long as Steve continues to fight for the Muppet’s integrity, they are still one and the same. I’ll be right here fighting alongside him and for them, even if Steve one day decides he’s had enough, although that in itself is doubtful. I also look forward to seeing what he’ll do as far as continuing on his career in puppetry. A new set of characters? A YouTube channel? Become a full-time monitor-puppetry teacher and lecturer perhaps? Only time will tell.

I’m also intrigued to see how the current Muppet Performers handle things as we go ahead with new projects. A lengthy period of adjustment will surely be needed for both them and us fans. There’s a lot of recasting to do. We already have Matt Vogel sitting on the Green Throne and apparently Peter Linz up in the balcony as Statler, but what about Lips, Beaker, Link, Newsman and Foo Foo? From the Vogel side of things, Robin the Frog faces an uncertain future. Matt is brilliant, but he can’t perform both uncle and nephew. Hopefully a new performer will be able to do Jerry Nelson justice. John Tartaglia, perhaps?

My main concern is for Rizzo the Rat. He was one of the last characters originated during the Muppet Show to still have his original performer. In all honesty, a huge part of me hopes that they’ll decide to retire him. Call me cynical, but I can’t see Rizzo becoming anything else but flanderized and shallow in the care of another puppeteer. He doesn’t have the same well-known depth as Kermit or Miss Piggy to dig into. That’s no slight against Steve in any way. In fact there’s no doubt in my mind that Steve had an entire backstory for Rizzo and why he became the character he is. Unfortunately, there wasn’t enough time given to Rizzo to flesh that all out and now he faces either a flat and shallow future or a complete redo.

That being said, I highly encourage a puppeteer to prove me wrong. In fact, I dare them to do so!

To collect the remaining mess of Muppet mumbles meandering around my mind, I’ll conclude by reiterating what I have been saying on Facebook, Muppet Central, in private conversations and the comment sections of Muppet Pundit.

I’ll break these down into simple statements:

  • Yes, I am still a Steve Whitmire fan; my loyalty remains with Steve.
  • I will be outspoken about the integrity of the Muppets and about my devotion to Jim Henson’s vision.
  • I will support Matt Vogel as Kermit and give him the period of adjustment he needs, but I am allowed to have a preference of performers.
  • I will also support any other recasts, but will reserve the right to preferences.
  • I will continue to watch and (hopefully) enjoy up and coming Muppet projects as we move forward, but won’t hesitate to call The Muppets Studio out on any mistakes or bad decision making.
  • I have nothing to say on the matter of Brian, Lisa and Cheryl Henson. Their thoughts are their own.
  • I will respect the opinions of fellow fans, but I can and will respectfully dispute and discuss differences of said opinions if I feel it is required.
  • I will not tolerate any fan who deliberately causes trouble with myself or any other fans for the sake of causing conflict. If I feel the need to defend myself or assist a victim of bullying, I will do so.

After five years of blindly following along and singing praises about Disney’s direction for the Muppets, recent events have opened my eyes and stemmed my ignorance. I’m not the same fan I was before and with Steve now out of the cast of performers, it’s going to take time to properly redefine myself. If there is anything I’m certain of, it’s that Jim Henson never could have imagined things playing out the way they have. That, above anything else, is the most disappointing aspect of all.

But I digress. May the next few months provide us with fresh minds and new hope for the characters we all know and love.

Until next time,

Marni Hill (JimAndFrank, @123Hillsy, etc)

Henson Articles Muppet Articles

Marni Hill View All →

Muppet Enthusiast, Film Lover, Book Adorer. No one original, but (hopefully) providing brand new perspectives for the world to process. Currently a Bachelor of Arts undergraduate at Deakin University.

7 Comments Leave a comment

  1. Surprised there are no replies on this post yet…


    So much of what you’ve written resonates with things I’ve been thinking these past two weeks, but have not put into words publicly. Thank you. Something in particular that you posted on the Muppet Central forum last week was the turning point for me to start making sense of this whole thing. In fact, I’m only now coming to realise how many things that I’ve read in different places, that I identified closely with, all turned out to be written by the same person… and one from my time zone at that ;). I wonder if we are… maybe not “soul sisters”, but… soul cousins??…

    Anyway, do keep up the good stuff,


    Liked by 1 person

    • J.S
      Soul-cousins it is!
      I’m always glad to hear that something I have said or written has influenced someone’s thinking in a positive way, but I don’t go out of my way to do so. Everything I have posted either on MC or here in the past two weeks are simply my attempts to make sense of things.

      Thanks for responding,



      • “Attempts to make sense of things” – plenty of that going around right now, no mistake.

        I don’t know what your social network is like. I don’t have any Muppet-obsessed friends or family to share my attempts with, so a lot of my thinking over the past few weeks has been pretty…. solitary. This is probably no use to you whatsoever, but if you ever decide you’d like to bounce some ideas off a fresh pair of eyes/ears, you’re always welcome to hit up my email address (which I’m guessing your website should have stored).




  2. A great read Marni and I’m with you all the way. Glad Steve asked you to re-post the link – I missed it first time around. I’m lucky to have worked with Steve – a wonderful man, an exceptional puppeteer and a person with a great generosity of spirit. I’m also terribly sad about Rizzo – one of my personal favourite characters. Anyway, just wanted to thank you for the post 🙂
    All the very best

    Liked by 1 person

  3. “I’ve always cared about Steve and the other performers more than the characters themselves.” – this pretty much sums up how I’ve always felt about the Muppets too. They’re not just characters to me, they are the living, breathing embodiment of a performing ensemble with more talent and creativity than I could ever hope to have. I think that’s why I love the behind-the-scenes stuff so much. The making-of magic is almost more interesting to me than the final product (which has always been thoroughly entertaining, at least in it’s heyday). You can’t have Rizzo and Gonzo without Steve and Dave. It’s the camaraderie and chemistry (I mean this is the most platonic of ways, lol) between them that makes the characters come alive, not just the voices or the script. That shared history between the performers and the characters allows them to play off of each other so beautifully. Same with Jim and Frank. I actually see Miss Piggy a little differently knowing that Frank Oz no longer performs her. She looks the same, she moves the same, she sounds (almost) the same…and yet, she’s not the same.

    Kind of a tangent, but related – I often feel like there’s a distinct difference between the fans that value the performers and see the magic in the behind-the-scenes, and the ones that primarily value the finished product. Does that make sense? To me at least, you can tell in the comments and opinions that have been expressed in the aftermath of Steve’s dismissal. Not that there’s necessarily anything wrong with either perspective – I just think that the more “casual” fans are missing out on a large piece of the puzzle. Just a weird observation…

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Marni, I don’t know if you remember, but this is the post that first brought you to my attention, and I complimented you on it via Steve’s blog, and that was basically the start of our friendship. I wanted to revisit it after your recent self-deprecation on Twitter.

    My perspective on the whole “situation” (what I call the Schism) has changed somewhat in the past two and a half years, but my opinion of your writing has not. I thought at the time, and I still think, that this post is exceptionally well-written and thoughtful, and that you set very reasonable boundaries in it.

    There’s nothing wrong with looking critically at your past work with an eye toward improvement. At the same time, I hope you can give yourself the credit you deserve, because you really do have a special talent for writing.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: